Indonesian children make perilous journey to school over collapsed bridge

Beawiharta / Reuters

Sofiah, right, and her friends walk to school at Sanghiang Tanjung village in Lebak regency, Banten, Indonesia on Jan. 19, 2012.

Beawiharta / Reuters

Students hold on to the side steel bars of a collapsed bridge as they cross a river to get to school in Sanghiang Tanjung on Jan. 19, 2012

For Sofiah and her classmates, the journey to school just got a whole lot harder. The Indonesian schoolgirl lives on one side of the Ciberang River but her school in the village of Sanghiang Tanjung is on the other - and the river has been flooding.

On Monday, the rising waters broke a pillar supporting a suspension bridge that crosses it, the head of the village told Reuters.

Faced with an extra 30 minutes' walk to cross via an alternate bridge, Sofiah and her friends have chosen to undertake the precarious crossing of the collapsed bridge instead.

 


As word has spread, the media gathered to film a feat worthy of Indiana Jones. But the children don't appear to be perturbed, safely making it across and continuing to school.

At least they have something to say when their parents ask, "What happened at school today?"

Beawiharta / Reuters

Sofiah, left, and her friend cross the bridge on Jan. 19, 2012.

Beawiharta / Reuters

Sofiah stands on a chair as she writes on a whiteboard after reaching school on Jan. 19, 2012.

Children in Indonesia are taking a perilous route to school using a broken suspension bridge. Msnbc.com's Dara Brown reports.

 

 

Discuss this post

Jump to discussion page: 1 ... 7 8 9

How do thier parents even allow them to cross that bridge anymore like that? Risking childrens lives just to save a half hour on thier "commute" to school? I dont think so. Get the kids out the door a half hour earlier so they get to school on time. At least until they can fix the bridge for them.

  • 1 vote
Reply#233 - Fri Jan 20, 2012 4:41 PM EST

I love how you stupid political dic k heads make this into some sort of political obama this or that thing. No wonder why you nimrods have no life. Go polute your stupid political crap somewhere else. This has nothing to do with america or american politics.

  • 2 votes
Reply#234 - Fri Jan 20, 2012 4:46 PM EST

Kallie, you are wrong! The facts are (and this is according to United Nations data) that our high school kids on average do not do as well as many kids in metropolitan high schools in other countries. Example: Shanghai, China, and Finland. Do not compare our standards with kids from rural schools in Asia since those are naturally disadvantaged due to lack of funds and other societal reasons. Compare city schools to city schools.

This is not to say that U.S. students aren't smart -- there are lots of them, and perhaps they think more creatively because they are not taught to learn by rote -- but facts are facts. The less time our kids spend on their iPods and the more time they spend in school the better. I am afraid we are losing our competitiveness to Asian countries.

    Reply#235 - Fri Jan 20, 2012 4:46 PM EST

    Wow. I guess all of our U.S. schools that are "naturally disadvantaged due to lack of funds and other societal reasons" shouldn't be compared too.

    In that case...you have no case.

    • 1 vote
    #235.1 - Fri Jan 20, 2012 4:55 PM EST
    Reply
    Comment author avatarGlenn Peachvia Facebook

    perhaps the local community does not have the funds to rebuild a bridge. But do you think their are a few boats around. Can't someone help these kids twice a day with a ride across the river?

      Reply#236 - Fri Jan 20, 2012 4:51 PM EST

      We have it pretty good in America. I read an article written by David Letterman that spelled it out so well.

      Americans were complaining about how unhappy and dissatisfied with the state of affairs in our country they are...

      Letterman wrote:

      1. Is it that Americans are dissatified with their 24 hours a day, and 7 days a week of electrical service and clean running water.

      2. Or Air Conditioning in the summer and Heat in the winter...

      3. Or the fact that 91.5% of us have a job...

      4. Is it the fact that we can walk to the grocery store and see more food in minutes than Darfur has seen in a year?

      5. Or the fact that we can drive our cars from the Atlantic Ocean to the Pacific Ocean without ever being stopped and asked for identification papers as we move through State to State...

      6. Or perhaps the hundreds of safe clean Motels we will find along the way to provide us with temporary shelter...

      7. Or the thousands of of restaurants with varying cusine from around the world...

      8. Or the firemen at our beckon-call that will save us and our belongings in the event of a fire... Or will helicopter us to a hospital if we wreck our car.

      9. Or for that matter the police that will come to save us from prowlers who might steal our multitude of flat screen TV's...

      10. Or our neighborhoods free from militias raping and pillaging the streets. Where 80% of teenagers have phones and computers...

      11. Or the fact that we have complete social, political and religious freedom in our country. Which is the envy of every country on earth.

      Times might be tough for us now in this recession... or maybe they are not that tough, but we are a country filled with spoiled people, who do not know what the word tough really is...

      • 3 votes
      Reply#237 - Fri Jan 20, 2012 4:53 PM EST

      Thank you. Exactly. Why is there so much Americans hating on their own country?

      If you don't like living here...GTFO.

      Simple.

        #237.1 - Fri Jan 20, 2012 4:59 PM EST
        Reply

        When seeing a picture such as this people tend to believe that the country, as a whole, is impoverished, when in fact it isn't. We need to remember that there are impoverished places in every country. For example, if I were to post a picture of a neighborhood in Beverly Hills, California, would you say that all Americans live in the same type of neighborhood? No, as Americans, you know better. Therefore, I am sure that the bridge will eventually be repaired after the threat of bad weather subsides.

        It never ceases to amaze me what most Americans consider to be wealth. I think most are blinded. For example, our society sees the higher priced automobile, cell phone, home or television as wealth, therefore leading us to believe that those who do not possess these items are impoverished, when in actuality, they are not.

        Like I said, I'm sure the bridge will be repaired eventually. No, the children should not have crossed it, but I did notice that an adult was crossing it as well. It may be that a lot of people are crossing it daily and therefore the children see it as being safe.

          Reply#238 - Fri Jan 20, 2012 5:25 PM EST

          By the way, all 2 digit numbers also need to be written as words in formal writing. 3 digit and above remain digits. And digits should never start a sentence (thought you got me, didn't you). But who cares in this simple-minded forum.

          Wake up America.

            Reply#239 - Fri Jan 20, 2012 6:13 PM EST

            These villagers aren't going catch nothing.

            We always set our trotlines in the water when we was trying to catch gators.

              Reply#240 - Fri Jan 20, 2012 6:30 PM EST

              I'm guessing not many of you noticed that the road they were walking on was a paved one? Not that it need be, just an observation. I will say, that in the eyes of most Americans, that the desks in the classroom would seem primitive and outdated, but why would we see them in this way? Well, because we tend to be a throw away society. For example, how many college books are thrown away each semester even though they contain the exact information as the newer ones that we are forced to buy in order to take a class? These books can and do cost hundreds of dollars. Why are they no longer usable? Well, it's because we are an advanced country, unlike others that use the same book more than three times. Wow, what a shame they have no clue.

              We are wasteful, yet seen as advanced?

              We are not advanced because we can get gaming aps on our cell phones. We are not advanced because we can inform people on facebook that we washed our hair today or changed the oil in the ol chevy. We are not advanced because there's a fast food place on practically every corner of our city. We are not advanced because we buy bottled water.

              In my opinion, a country that is advanced, is a self sufficent one. It has nothing to do with technology or what one uses to bake bread. The bottom line is, we need water, food and shelter. We are traveling backwards in our attempt to obtain these things. We are a society that can no longer distinguish between a want and a need. That's the real shame.

                Reply#241 - Fri Jan 20, 2012 7:03 PM EST

                all i have to say is...if you were those kids, and you where in their shoes...what would you do? keep in mind. in south east asia, if you were consider to be the top student you will get a chance to go to higher edu. and make a name for yourself. the end result is you will land a job with some top official. so, to say those kids or parent are not responsible... you don't understand their reason why they need to make it to school everyday.

                  Reply#242 - Fri Jan 20, 2012 7:10 PM EST

                  I’m 16 years old and found myself interested in this story. Feeling sympathetic I decided to read these comments just to see everyone’s opinions. All I have to say is “wow” you guys sure have a lot of different opinions. I read almost all of them and felt a great need to give my opinion as well.

                  I read quite a few that constantly bashed “me” and to my opinion yes me. I am an American kid and it was unfair to me that we didn’t have a say in this discussion. Yes I may be only 16 commenting on an adult argument but I feel a child’s opinion can also be valued. Please don’t make an attempt to gather the assumption that I think I’m better than those Indonesian children I do understand that we come from different backgrounds some more unfortunate then others.

                  While reading your comments I tried to keep an open mind and try to understand what made you come up with your conclusions and am going to try my best not to offend people which may be unavoidable. Ok first of all I was extremely shocked to see grown adults literally bash their own children. When kids grow up in an automated world extra manual labor may seem pointless to them. Parents you have to try and see it from their point of view. It’s not our fault we grow up in this world same goes for those Indonesian children. They adapted to their world as did I in mine. (World being used as the meaning of situation)

                  We are two completely different places. Yes America is more fortunate than others but we to have our downfalls. I love computers and technology because I grew up around it. I will admit I do enjoy a video game every now and then. To a kid’s point of view they are fun, it’s not necessarily a horrible thing. What was fun when you guys were little is not what fun is now. Would you like your parents wanting to take away what was fun for you? Did you know in South Korea they have LAN Gaming Centers all over in which they go just to play MMO games? America hasn’t yet gotten that hardcore yet so America actually isn’t that bad with gaming as other countries can be. I will admit it makes you lazy and fat blah blah but hey what can you do. If you got rid of video games a gazillion people would lose their jobs and then BAM increase in unemployment. (Just sayin)(Purely my opinion sorry got carried away)(This paragraph is troll friendly so troll away)

                  The world will advance and there is nothing you can do about it. In the 1920’s during the Scopes trial (I learned this in history at school where I do in fact pay attention) the American Fundamentalists couldn’t accept the fact that America was moving on from what they were accustomed to. So I do understand your opinions on that matter are only a natural response to the world advancing in an unfavorable direction to you. It may sound as if I’ve completely strayed on my topic but trust me it does make my point on the kids are lazy in America issue.

                  These Indonesian children here are kids I respect to the fullest. They are brave and relentless to the world of knowledge. Although there trek to school may be fatal they still insist on going. That’s pretty awesome, it’s unfortunate that the bridge broke and I hope it can be fixed soon. My knowledge of their country is little but I did before writing this read up on a couple articles about Indonesia and Banten. Reading all these comments provoked me to pursue your issues so in a way I guess I can thank you guys. I hope I don’t get trolled hardcore for this but I only felt I was entitled to my opinion as well. I trust people will understand that I mean no disrespect by this comment and will judge it accordingly. THANKS!

                  • 2 votes
                  Reply#243 - Fri Jan 20, 2012 7:35 PM EST

                  Yes America is more fortunate than others but we to have our downfalls. I love computers and technology because I grew up around it...

                  At the risk of being "That guy!"... Take a moment to think about what you just said.

                  You proclaim that we are "more fortunate" as if it the difference was Luck. Facts tell a much different tale - early in our history, we decided that Universal education was a priority - not just a right for the rich. Even more important; ... We then did something about. In almost every community After the saloon, the Jail and the court house were built... communities built a school and a church.

                  This not a less than subtle dig at any other culture or peoples - its just a fact. One of the most generous things that America did for itself was to found schools as a requirement for civility. it was based on a desire to give the next generation something which very few families; one on one would be able to provide to their children, but as a community, it was possible.

                  All the kid was required to do is show up, sit down, listen and learn. The community taxed itself, often went without an extra hand to do "chores", so at least one of their children could attend school.

                  That legacy requires a continuing commitment. So, lets not say we are fortunate... its just not as easy you make it sound. If it were - everyone would be doing it.

                  We pay for our schools, we earned the right to send our kids to them - its not "fortune" - its commitment!

                  It ain't Luck - its hard work, done over generations ...call it compound interest, that is paying the community back in the the work of the next generation.

                  Pay it forward.

                  • 1 vote
                  #243.1 - Sun Jan 22, 2012 2:38 PM EST
                  Reply

                  Did everyone miss the fact that there is another bridge if they just left home a half hour sooner? I am pretty sure that is what I would do, even if I was a kid and it looked fun. I would also make sure that my children would leave home a half hour early to take the other bridge, even if they thought it would be fun to cross the broken one. I don't think that it is very smart parenting to allow it, when there is another choice,and because of the bridges condition it probably takes quite a bit longer to get there any way , so I am sure that taking the other bridge doen't add much more time to the trip. I really don't think this is something to be comending them for. Also I don't understand how this article would bring on any bashing of Americans.??? Where oh where has all the common sense gone?

                    Reply#244 - Fri Jan 20, 2012 9:33 PM EST

                    No different then when my parents warned us not to go through the parks after dark or always wear our bike helment... don't swim in creeks or farm ponds..yada, yada, yada.

                    The only way to guarantee that kids will take the safe route is to either tear the bridge down all the way or post a guard to prevent them from taking the short cut.

                    Only an extra 30 minute walk? Hell you drive by the local school and they won't even wait at the corner for the light to change, the crosswalk guard help them cross. The high school kids run across 4, 6 lanes of trafffic to avoid walking to the end of the block.

                    • 1 vote
                    #244.1 - Sun Jan 22, 2012 1:51 AM EST

                    I understand this. As hard as childhood is in a place like rural Indonesia, and as dangerous as day-to-day living can be, I certainly can see why they wouldn't want to waste an extra half-hour each way, an hour each day total. And I admire the dedication. And I hope that everyone sees how important education is and how much that they value it. Here, of course, we would never tolerate that bridge and it would be destroyed as the possible cause of a lawsuit. And many of the kids would then refuse to go to school at all if it took an extra half-hour each way, and many of the parents would back them and demand the right to take them out of school or that school be shut until the situation was remedied. I refuse to judge these people for not being American, and am glad that some of the rest of these people on here join in that.

                      #244.2 - Sun Jan 22, 2012 3:06 PM EST
                      Reply

                      I'm an Indonesian who now live in USA. Believe me, these photos are just a small picture of being a student in my home country, Indonesia.

                      School in Indonesia is indeed expensive and hard, People!

                      That's why.. Sometimes I can't stand when students here complain too much. In here, if you are poor, you still can go to school as there is financial aid, etc. You just need to put a little bit effort in.

                      In Indonesia, school and education are still A HUGE DREAM for most of the people.
                      *teary eyes*

                      • 1 vote
                      Reply#245 - Fri Jan 20, 2012 11:43 PM EST
                      Comment author avatarHeru Supanjivia Facebook

                      I proud of them... They are the future leader which I have.

                      • 1 vote
                      Reply#246 - Sat Jan 21, 2012 4:48 AM EST
                      Comment author avatarHeru Supanjivia Facebook

                      I need your permition to repost on my blog WINA PRIVATE COURSE

                      Thank you dear sir!

                        Reply#247 - Sat Jan 21, 2012 5:16 AM EST

                        There is no such thing called the next bridge, only a distant alternative pathetic path covered with water n mud, less than 1 meter in width, no bus can pass it, only a helicopter can save you from being a swamp thing at school. n Indonesia aint begging for your donation, our congressmen r about to build Rp 20 billion water closet n Rp 80 billion meeting hall... YOU KNOW T_T..!! ..Remember those kids, who creep between death n the school activity

                          Reply#248 - Sat Jan 21, 2012 1:43 PM EST

                          And yet at my HIGH SCHOOL they don't allow kids to walk or bike to school...

                            Reply#249 - Sun Jan 22, 2012 1:29 AM EST

                            and so the danger crossing would be ????crocodiles in the water ? falling in and drowning ?

                            forgive me, but tell me again, just why this particular bridge couldn't be fixed too just as the alternative 30 minutes longer around alternate one was.....

                            i agree with whomever said "American kids should be jealous to have such an Indiana Jones feat to attempt." Remember the nights of playing out in the street under the street light, catching fire flies and playing hide and seek or playing war games running thru brush and grass and rolling on the ground......these children obviously WANT an education and do what it takes to get to school. Pay attention American teens who ditch, smoke dope in the parking lot and think your parents are idiots.....we aren't and we really do know what you're doing.

                            • 1 vote
                            Reply#250 - Sun Jan 22, 2012 1:04 PM EST

                            Are you missing what I see?

                            That water is fast moving and the ripples in the surface promise that there is more underwater than just a smooth sandy bottom, the remnants of the bridge appear to be 40 - 50 ft above the water...

                            To me, I see a lot of danger if a small child were unfortunate enough to take an unexpected plunge into those waters fully clothed.

                            If the kid survived the fall - there is a real question of whether they would make the right choice of which bank to swim toward. Or even make it without being entangled in something underwater or being carried downstream.

                            I see, in one of the pictures... what looks like an adult (possibly the father of one of the girls) walking on a lower cable - just in case?

                              #250.1 - Sun Jan 22, 2012 2:48 PM EST
                              Reply

                              Why not start a school on the other side of the bridge, where these kids live? It would seem better to have ONE or TWO teachers walk the bridge daily, then to have a multitude of children do it?! Of course, it would be dangerous for them as well. You would think some of the 'adults' around there would be able to think of a way to, at least, make a few repairs to make the bridge less dangerous. Who built it in the first place??

                                Reply#251 - Sun Jan 22, 2012 4:58 PM EST

                                Indonesians are always bad in risk management

                                  Reply#252 - Mon Jan 23, 2012 7:30 AM EST

                                  When i was a 1st grader many a times i skiied to school crosscountry about 1 1/2 miles oneway. Temperatures often at minus 25 region. and dark to boot apart from stars and moon because of late sunrise. One time because of the blizzard dad had to come and pick me up from school on the horseback as that was the only way to get ahead. My home was about 62 northern latitude. Schools were always open. Americans have it easy.

                                    Reply#253 - Thu Jan 26, 2012 5:59 PM EST
                                    Jump to discussion page: 1 ... 7 8 9
                                    You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
                                    As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.