Puppy refuses to leave his dead mother's side following ethnic violence in Myanmar

(Updated Nov. 14)

GRAPHIC WARNING: This post contains graphic images which some viewers may find disturbing. 

Minzayar / Reuters

Minzayar / Reuters

The puppy with its mother a day earlier on Nov. 5.

A puppy stays by the remains of a dog who local residents say is its mother on Nov. 6 (above), days after it was killed in an area burned in violence at East Pikesake ward in Kyaukphyu, Myanmar. The exact circumstances of the dog's death are unknown.

 

Update (Nov. 14): Many readers wondered about the fate of the puppy. We contacted Reuters and they informed us that after the pictures were taken the puppy was taken to a nearby monastery. The photographer, who uses the byline Minzayar, also responded in our comments section: 

When I was walking around the burnt areas in that villages, I saw this scene which broke my heart. Before taking pics, I asked the local people around who would adopt the puppy. No one couldn't because they are all in difficulty themselves suffered from the communal violence. Then, I dropped all my cameras, just sitting and watching the little puppy with the deepest sympathy and sorrows, cries inside me. Then I took the pictures. I rubbed its head... He licked my hands.. Then after a few minutes, took the pictures again.. When my time comes that I must leave, I was about to take the puppy back to the hotel but then, there was one very kind local man who has been watching me and the puppy. He said he also wants to adopt it but cannot because he is poor. Then finally, we decided to send the puppy back to the Buddhist monastery in the village. In Myanmar, monasteries are believed to be the most peaceful place than everything. I believe I did what I could do best in my given situations.
I will surely pay a visit to the puppy again sometime in the future.

To add, me and the local man picked up the puppy together..

Related content:

Sign up for the NBCNews.com Photos Newsletter

 

Discuss this post

Hey photographer ....I hope that you put the camera down ...and picked the puppy up. Or did you just walk away like everyone else ?

  • 6 votes
Reply#1 - Mon Nov 12, 2012 12:24 PM EST

Yeah, saving that puppy should be on the top of his priority list. I take it you don't watch the news very much?

Maybe read up on what those people are going through right now. Or just ignore it like everyone else (ouch, too soon?)

presstv.com/detail/2012/07/19/251725/world-ignoring-myanmar-muslims-plight/

  • 1 vote
#1.1 - Mon Nov 12, 2012 11:06 PM EST

testure ....I am well aware of what is going on in the region.....Compassion knows no species you jack ass ....

  • 7 votes
#1.2 - Tue Nov 13, 2012 1:08 PM EST

Umm... Did you miss this part of the article? Well actually MSN updates its article. But yes he did! Poor puppy and mommy :(

When I was walking around the burnt areas in that villages, I saw this scene which broke my heart. Before taking pics, I asked the local people around who would adopt the puppy. No one couldn't because they are all in difficulty themselves suffered from the communal violence. Then, I dropped all my cameras, just sitting and watching the little puppy with the deepest sympathy and sorrows, cries inside me. Then I took the pictures. I rubbed its head... He licked my hands.. Then after a few minutes, took the pictures again.. When my time comes that I must leave, I was about to take the puppy back to the hotel but then, there was one very kind local man who has been watching me and the puppy. He said he also wants to adopt it but cannot because he is poor. Then finally, we decided to send the puppy back to the Buddhist monastery in the village. In Myanmar, monasteries are believed to be the most peaceful place than everything. I believe I did what I could do best in my given situations.
I will surely pay a visit to the puppy again sometime in the future.

To add, me and the local man picked up the puppy together..

  • 3 votes
#1.3 - Fri Nov 16, 2012 5:05 PM EST

pvaldes, read the article jackass! or cant you read.

    #1.4 - Mon Nov 19, 2012 2:55 PM EST

    "...hope that you put the camera down ...and picked the puppy up."

    Another candidate for the 'Reading is Fundamental' program.

    • 2 votes
    #1.5 - Thu Nov 22, 2012 7:19 PM EST

    Nov 12, 2012: PValdes' comment regarding photographer's reaction to puppy.

    Nov 14, 2012: NBC's article update to include photographer's comments and puppy's fate, both of which were absent up to that point.

    Nov 16-22, 2012: Three people commenting on failure of PValdes' reading comprehension, e.g. "Another candidate for the 'Reading is Fundamental' program." (The first of you even mentioned that "Well actually MSN updates its article." Yet that still didn't deter the two ridiculous follow-up responses.)

    You three may want to more carefully consider who is failing at reading comprehension. I suggest that a mirror may be a useful tool.

    • 1 vote
    #1.6 - Sat Nov 24, 2012 1:38 PM EST
    Reply

    I really hope there are still good people in this world, and someone picked that poor puppy up.... one of the saddest pictures I have seen.

    • 5 votes
    Reply#2 - Mon Nov 12, 2012 1:44 PM EST

    This photo is heartbreaking. Hey NBC/Reuters, did someone help that poor animal?

    • 5 votes
    Reply#3 - Mon Nov 12, 2012 2:09 PM EST

    If you could bring the puppy back to the U.S., I will adopt it. But please, don't leave it!

    • 6 votes
    Reply#4 - Mon Nov 12, 2012 2:13 PM EST
    Reply

    If you could bring the animal back to the States, I will adopt it. That's a promise

    • 5 votes
    Reply#5 - Mon Nov 12, 2012 2:18 PM EST

    sad :(

    I am always stunned at the emotional capability of any animal, I love them

    • 7 votes
    Reply#6 - Mon Nov 12, 2012 3:22 PM EST

    Please let us know if you saved this beautiful puppy.

    I understand the need to be a neutral observer when your a journalist but I hope your humanity took over and you saved this scared lonely creature. ..

    • 4 votes
    Reply#7 - Mon Nov 12, 2012 4:36 PM EST
    Comment author avatarJamie Adamvia Facebook

    oh my god that's so sad! Yeah, photog, you better have adopted that poor little baby!

    • 3 votes
    Reply#8 - Mon Nov 12, 2012 5:32 PM EST

    Wow.. seriously people? Everybody here is so concerned about the dog, and yes it's quite sad- but it's not the photographer's responsibility to save it. If you're so concerned buy a plane ticket to burma and see what's going on there first hand, maybe the puppy won't be so fresh on your mind once you see the violence around you.

    What about the murder and violence being done to humans? If the photographer turned 180 degrees he could probably have taken a picture of a blasted out home or a dead human being. Should he be responsible for their families, homes, children? I think not.

    Seriously people, wake up.

    • 1 vote
    Reply#9 - Mon Nov 12, 2012 6:36 PM EST

    Here's an idea--if you're worried about people, do something to help people. If other people want to help dogs, let them help dogs. But keep your idiotic judgements to yourself.

    • 10 votes
    #9.1 - Mon Nov 12, 2012 9:04 PM EST

    Here's a better idea, let's jump to conclusions! That's a lot easier than rubbing two brain cells together to form a coherent thought. But I guess you'd need two in the first place, right?

    Read these comments. Nobody here wants to help the dog- they want someone else to do it. They want to sleep easy at night knowing that somebody else fixed the situation. My point is that all of these bleeding hearts posting about the photographer needing to 'save the dog' have never seen a humanitarian crisis in their life. A photographer just waded through immeasurable human suffering to capture a symbolic photo of the crisis, and the world at large misses the point entirely. Congrats.

    Or maybe I'm wrong? I bet one of these good Samaritans bought a plane ticket and took the first flight to Burma and that puppy will have a home in no time. Right.

    • 3 votes
    #9.2 - Mon Nov 12, 2012 11:02 PM EST

    Here's an idea... Everybody who wants to aid animals... donate. There are plenty of shelters probably right down the road from whereever you live that NEED money, blankets, dog food, toys, water and food dishes, etc.

    This Puppy HAS BEEN adopted by a monastery....geez folks...

    The mere fact that this photo even reached your p.c. , and touched us in the way it has, was because this photographer decided that in this moment of time that "WE" should see this tragic and moving moment.

    So Kudos to the Photographer ... Kudos to the monastery... and Kudos to all the shelters...

    Please now,

    PLAY NICE

    • 7 votes
    #9.3 - Wed Nov 14, 2012 12:00 PM EST

    What a very poignant photo that says so much about babies. Such an incredible shot of a starving puppy dependent upon its dead mother for love, nutrition and guidance.Which is beyond reach, but this puppy won't abandon that bond. Because it doesn't understand death is yet.

    Many comments seem focused on what the photographer did or didn't do about this puppy. We all have opportunities in life to make a difference. Frequently they come when we least expect them. And most times we don't realize them for what they are. This photographer had the opportunity to step in and intervene for a little puppy destined to die by its mother. Which he did, with the help of a local man. Now that sweet, helpless puppy has a second chance at a better life with some monks.

    How often does each of us have the chance to make a positive impact in others lives, which we don't even realize? It doesn't have to be a huge gut-wrenching moment or heroic feat even. How about when you are driving, see someone trying to get onto the freeway. Do you slow down to let someone safely merge into traffic or switch lanes? Or give up your seat to another who is older or carrying items, open a door ,buy a meal for a homeless person or get them a blanket or mittens/hat/scarf. Help an elderly person get their trash out to the curb. The fact is there are countless opportunities to serve others around you every day.

    One doesn't have to go half way around the world to find others who could use a helping hand.We each can touch lives, lift up hearts and give hope to others if we just keep our eyes opened.Instead of shutting ourselves off to the rest of humanity and just focusing on ourselves and our needs only. If you just reach out, you'll discover your potential to help change the world.Making it a better place because you are in it.

    • 6 votes
    #9.4 - Thu Nov 15, 2012 3:48 PM EST

    People for a large measure create their own problems, mostly because of their clueless behavior, outdated and foolish magical thinking, dysfunctional need for control, and generally depend on others to protect them from the real world they know would eat them alive, and fear, if a riot or natural disaster struck them..

    This puppy did not create his tragic situation, it was forced on him by the same stupid human behavior that has been shown again and again by fanatics and religious crazies.

    We are the voices of these innocent and unconditionally loving animals, if they have been raised to be loving - "have never met a bad pet, only bad pet owners" - and even if we can not afford to fly to rescue this little furry friend, people still have to right to wish someone else who does have some control over this horrible event will interact to save this helpless creature.

    Animals are like children, they only grow up to be what they are taught in life, when not overprotected and become dependent, and lost when their teacher passes on.

    • 4 votes
    #9.5 - Sat Nov 17, 2012 5:19 AM EST

    The only comment I would add to your post, Carl Gee, is that I found the picure of this puppy symbolic of TRUE unconditional love...

    • 2 votes
    #9.6 - Tue Nov 20, 2012 8:33 AM EST

    Anyone who can (the key word is can as in able) alleviate the suffering of the dog has the responsibiliby to do so. No manmade laws exist to require helping animals, and some manmade laws exist to forbide help. But the responsibility still exists.

    • 1 vote
    #9.7 - Fri Nov 23, 2012 1:11 PM EST

    The plight of the people is surely abysmal, but people, whether leaders, followers, etc., are also the CAUSE of all these tragic situations. At some point, however, the "world" will step in and offer some kind of assistance for relief. It may be that the offered relief is too little, too late for many, but I can guarantee animals will not benefit one whit from any assistance.

    I would not hesitate to help any animal in need......in fact, I am a rescuer. I'm not so fond of the human race, but I will even offer a helping hand to the species that has torn this planet so asunder that it may never return from the path to extinction. Conversely, not enough people help animals, self righteously claiming that "We need to let Nature take care of its own. " THAT being the case, we should let Nature take care of US, as well!! That would solve MILLIONS of problems.

      #9.8 - Sat May 4, 2013 10:05 AM EDT
      Reply
      Comment author avatarEmily Irvingvia Facebook

      please tell me someone picked up this puppy! anyone!

      • 2 votes
      Reply#10 - Mon Nov 12, 2012 7:13 PM EST

      I hope someone saved the animal; this is a very sad photo and the more I look at it the worse I feel.

      Tester: one person alone cannot save the world or stop a war. I cannot afford to buy plan tickets and go see the horrors that are taking place in Burma, nor would I be more than a liability if I went there... but I still feel very bad when I see a baby of any species trying to gain comfort from its dead mother, anyone of sound mind would be disheartened by such pictures.

      I don’t think that people need to "wake up" because they are affected by these images. Just because there are more horrible things going on does not make the puppy’s situation any less sad. Why would you criticize people for carrying about the animal?

      • 5 votes
      Reply#11 - Mon Nov 12, 2012 7:26 PM EST

      [wrong reply]

        Reply#12 - Mon Nov 12, 2012 11:01 PM EST

        Saving one dog will not change the world, but it will change the world for the dog. There is no harm in wanting to rescue the puppy. If we were seeing a confused human child, we could reasonably expect family to be around to help the child. There is structure for helping orphaned human children, be it official or not. An orphaned puppy, who has likely lost all siblings as well? It's natural for our hearts to go out and want to help. That's perfectly normal.

        • 6 votes
        Reply#13 - Tue Nov 13, 2012 12:31 AM EST

        Can't control my tears. The more I look, the more I cry.

        • 3 votes
        Reply#14 - Tue Nov 13, 2012 1:26 PM EST

        I want to do something. What town, what location is this take? I am going to Burma.

        • 3 votes
        Reply#15 - Tue Nov 13, 2012 10:06 PM EST

        Hi:

        Was in Thailand for 5 days on R&R in January of 1968.

        A noble desire on your part, but it seems everything has been taken care of by other concerned persons. Hopefully we will be getting some photos of the puppy looking better fed and healthy soon. Would luv to find a way to get this puppy brought to the USA, or anywhere he has a happy and loving home.

        Take care of things you can more easily control. Do what you can locally to improve life for your neighbors and furry friends, and Karma and the "The Threefold Law" of the Goddess www.wicca.com/celtic/wicca/wicca.htm will repay you.

        Plus you will gain more inner-peace and strength, and have greater Harmony and Serenity to pass to others.

        Wise and Blessed Be. "An ye harm none, do as ye will."

        • 2 votes
        #15.1 - Sat Nov 17, 2012 7:14 AM EST
        Reply

        How can i get in touch with the reporter? Or the camera man/woman? I have to do something. This image breaks me.

        • 2 votes
        Reply#16 - Tue Nov 13, 2012 10:10 PM EST

        Good news: We contacted Reuters and were told that after the pictures were taken the puppy was taken to a nearby monastery.

        • 1 vote
        Reply#17 - Wed Nov 14, 2012 10:43 AM EST

        Some photos would be, "Oh so nice."

        • 1 vote
        #17.1 - Sat Nov 17, 2012 5:58 AM EST
        Reply

        Mr. Nighswander, could we get pictures of that puppy in the monastery?

        • 1 vote
        Reply#18 - Wed Nov 14, 2012 11:39 AM EST

        When i was walking around the burnt areas in that villages, I saw this scene which broke my heart . Before taking pics, I asked the local people around who would adopt the puppy. No one couldn't because they are all in difficulty themselves suffered from the communal violence. Then, I dropped all my cameras, just sitting and watching the little puppy with the deepest sympathy and sorrows, cries inside me. Then i took the pictures. I rubbed its head... He licked my hands.. Then after a few minutes, took the pictures again.. When my time comes that I must leave, I was about to take the puppy back to the hotel but then, there was one very kind local man who has been watching me and the puppy. He said he also wants to adopt it but cannot because he is poor. Then finally, we decided to send the puppy back to the Buddhist monastery in the village. In Myanmar, monasteries are believed to be the most peaceful place than everything. I believe I did what I could do best in my given situations.
        I will surely pay a visit to the puppy again sometime in the future.

        To add, me and the local man picked up the puppy together..

        Best..

        • 2 votes
        Reply#19 - Wed Nov 14, 2012 3:06 PM EST

        The face of suffering. For those that believe in re birth, that could very well be me or you in our future.

        • 2 votes
        Reply#20 - Thu Nov 15, 2012 9:05 PM EST

        Made me cry just looking at the poor baby next to his/her mother. Happy that the photographer and other many took the puppy to what is hopefully a safe place.

        • 1 vote
        Reply#21 - Fri Nov 16, 2012 6:30 AM EST

        Thanks for the update. I needed that closure. This is a very emotional picture.

        • 1 vote
        Reply#22 - Sat Nov 17, 2012 1:00 AM EST

        gosh.....if everyone read the orignal post.....ummm dog was saved....and we could have been spared all this extra posting..... but now we can all happy, happy...no worries...sleep tight don.t let the bedbugs bite....oh i think i see a bedbug withouts it mother......ohhhh nooooo....i shall take it to a happy happy place. peace out people have a great thanksgiving....oh is that a baby turkey i see.....

          Reply#23 - Sat Nov 17, 2012 12:50 PM EST

          The poor man was probably a hungry guy....took the puppy home and made some nice puppy stew. "Yeah lady, I'll take him to the monastery." The lady only cared about getting the sad photos...and didn't really care in the first place. This is real human nature...not the stuff the psychologists would like us to believe.

            Reply#24 - Sun Nov 18, 2012 4:57 PM EST

            you are poo...

              #24.1 - Sun May 5, 2013 6:19 PM EDT
              Reply
              You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
              As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.