• MSN
  • Hotmail
  • More
    • Autos
    • My MSN
    • Video
    • Careers & Jobs
    • Personals
    • Weather
    • Delish
    • Quotes
    • White Pages
    • Games
    • Real Estate
    • Wonderwall
    • Horoscopes
    • Shopping
    • Yellow Pages
    • Local Edition
    • Traffic
    • Feedback
    • Maps & Directions
    • Travel
    • Full MSN Index
  • Bing
  • NBCNews.com
  • TODAY
  • Nightly News
  • Rock Center
  • Meet the Press
  • Dateline
  • msnbc
  • Breaking News
  • Newsvine
  • Home
  • US
  • World
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Health
  • Tech
  • Science
  • Travel
  • Local
  • Weather
Advertise | AdChoices
  • Recommended: The Week in Pictures: May 9 - 16
  • Recommended: Border security improvements create new deadly route for illegal immigrants
  • Recommended: Life-saving surgery for baby with swollen head brings parents joy, relief
  • Recommended: Farmers fight back against swarming locusts in Israel

Conversations sparked by photojournalism. Follow us on Twitter to keep up-to-date.

  • ↓ About this blog
  • ↓ Archives
    • Icons Email E-mail updates
    • Icons Twitter Follow on Twitter
    • Icons Feed Subscribe to RSS
  • 28
    Feb
    2012
    6:45am, EST

    Michigan highlights the contrast of style in GOP race

    John Makely / msnbc.com

    The marquee sign of the Royal Oak theater in Royal Oak, Michigan announces the invitation only rally for Mitt Romney on the eve of the Republican primary election in his home state of Michigan.

    John Makely / msnbc.com

    Senator Rick Santorum has a quick bite to eat before the speaking to the Livonia Chamber of Commerce in Livonia, Michigan on Monday, Feb. 27. On the menu were mini quiches, muffins, sausages and mixed fruit.

    By John Makely, NBC News

    A few weeks ago I spent ten days in New Hampshire covering the run up to the Republican primary on Jan. 10.  This week I briefly returned to the campaign trail as Mitt Romney and Rick Santorum vie for the attention of Michigan voters before the primary there on Feb. 28.  While Romney's campaign bankroll has enabled him to spend heavily on staff, promotional material and airtime I was still struck by the stark contrasts in style as I covered both Romney and Santorum events on Monday. 

    John Makely / msnbc.com

    Security was tight as
    Mitt Romney addressed supporters gathered at the Caster Concepts company in Albion, Michigan. Those who turned out for the event were directed to areas around the stage, which was illuminated with theatrical lighting. Press risers were assembled for the media to offer a view of all the people in attendance.

    John Makely / msnbc.com

    Senator Rick Santorum makes a point while speaking before the Livonia Chamber of Commerce in Livonia, Michigan on Monday, Feb. 27.

    John Makely / msnbc.com

    Surrounded by supporters on a carefully arranged stage wit oversized banners,
    Mitt Romney addresses primary voters gathered at the Caster Concepts company in Albion, Michigan. The crowd responded with applause following each talking point.

    John Makely / msnbc.com

    Senator Rick Santorum speaks before the Livonia Chamber of Commerce in Livonia, Michigan on Monday, Feb. 27. The senator earned a hearty applause from the crowd for comments supporting the U.S. troops, lowering taxes and his emphasis on the need to replace President Obama with a Republican.

    John Makely / msnbc.com

    Bob Pohl, of Spring Arbor, Michigan, ( second from left) holds up an old capmaign poster of George Romney, Mitt Romney's father, during a rally at the Caster Concepts company in Albion, Michigan.

    John Makely / msnbc.com

    Senator Rick Santorum shakes hands with a supporter after speaking to the Livonia Chamber of Commerce in Livonia, Michigan on Monday, Feb. 27.

    John Makely / msnbc.com

    Mitt Romney thanks Kid Rock after he and his band performed at the rally supporting Romney's campaign for President held at the Royal Oak theater in Royal Oak, Michigan on the eve of the Republican primary election in his home state of Michigan.

    Story: Michigan a testing ground for doubt on Romney

    • Story: Social issues? Santorum says he's talking about freedom
    • Story: Romney and Santorum court Michigan's key blue-collar voters
    • Slideshow: Rick Santorum
    • Slideshow: Mitt Romney

    2 comments

    Not a black face in the crowd, nor a Chinese, nor any other minority.

    Show more
    Explore related topics: election, politics, mitt-romney, rick-santorum, michigan-primary, decision-2012, john-makely
  • 5
    Jan
    2012
    5:31pm, EST

    New Hampshire voters take a second look at Santorum

    Rayf Ruot and his wife Deanna, from Barnstead, N.H. are undecided voters. "Something in my heart has been telling me to look into this guy a little," Rayf said, adding " I want to see where he stands with Israel. The prosperity of this country depends on the relationship with Israel. The Bible is very clear about that." The couple stay warm next to a working pot-bellied stove while waiting for  Republican Presidential candidate Rick Santorum at a "Faith, Family and Freedom" Town Hall event held at the Merrimack Valley Railroad in Northfield, N.H. Thursday.

    John Makely / msnbc.com

    Msnbc.com's John Makely and Mike O'Brien are in New Hampshire this week talking to voters about what they're looking for in a candidate. Read the full story.

     

    Republican Presidential candidate Rick Santorum presents his ideas at a "Faith, Family and Freedom" Town Hall event held at the Merrimack Valley Railroad in Northfield, New Hampshire.

    Meet Iowa voters, and learn what issues matters most to them as they consider a candidate

    Iowa voters describe the characteristics they're looking for in a candidate

    Follow @msnbc_pictures

     

    Comment

    Show more
    Explore related topics: candidates, new-hampshire, presidential-race, us-news, john-makely, nbc-politics
  • 22
    Dec
    2011
    9:55am, EST

    Take a spin on the ice at Rockefeller Center

    By John Makely, NBC News

    When I was a little kid growing up outside of New York City, my family always tried to make the yearly trip to Rockefeller Plaza to see the Christmas tree and the holiday displays at the department stores. The skating rink and the Plaza have always felt like a special place around the holidays, full of energy and perhaps a bit of nostalgia as well, at least for me.

     Opened in 1936, The Ice Skating Rink at Rockefeller Center celebrates its 75th year as one of the most visited attractions in New York City. The panorama above is a composite of over 65 separate photographs merged together to represent an immersive 360-degree view from the center of the ice.

     Below is a video from Brian Williams on the history of the ice rink and a time-lapse video of the installation of the 12-ton, 2011 Christmas tree.

    People have been hitting the ice at Rockefeller Center since 1936. Today, the ice skating rink is one of the most visited New York destinations during the holiday season. Brian Williams gives a special tour of the rink and looks back on its history.

    Watch as our cameras capture the intricate process that transforms and illuminates a 12-ton Christmas tree in New York City's Rockefeller Plaza.

    Follow @msnbc_pictures

    10 comments

    I just landed a triple axel!!!

    Show more
    Explore related topics: skating, holidays, christmas-tree, rockefeller-center, featured, panoramic, john-makely
  • 15
    Nov
    2011
    8:35am, EST

    Watching and waiting: Dispatches from the disputed streets of lower Manhattan

    Jonathan D. Woods / msnbc.com

    People crowd on a street in downtown New York City early on Nov. 15, after the police cleared Zuccotti Park and protesters were pushed into the side streets.

    Msnbc.com's John Makely and Jonathan Woods have been photographing the scenes around Zuccotti Park in lower Manhattan since the early hours of Tuesday morning. They gave a few impressions of what they have seen.

    Jonathan Woods writes:

    I got here around 3 a.m. ET and I really didn’t know what to expect. The first thing I saw when I walked onto Worth Street was a pile of dozens of bags of trash that the protesters had thrown into the street.

    As I walked closer to Zuccotti Park the police presence became overwhelming. The streets surrounding the park were heavily barricaded.

    Scuffles between police and protesters were few and far between -- most of those that I did see involved people refusing to get back on the sidewalk.

    Jonathan D. Woods / msnbc.com

    Police and protesters near Zuccotti Park on Nov. 15.

    As I write it's 7.30 a.m. and most people are standing around waiting for somethign to happen. Protesters and press are thinly lining the sidewalks. It's turned into a waiting game.

    Looking at Zuccotti Park, with the exception of the police and cleaning crews, if you hadn’t been aware of what transpired here since September 17, you would have no idea there had been a camp there until a few hours ago. It's alarmingly clean, it's spotless.

    As New Yorkers made their morning commutes, some were surprised to see the park clear of the protesters. One woman passing by was rejoicing at how clean it was. She kept exclaiming, "It’s beautiful, the park is beautiful!" as she went.

    Follow @jonwoods

     

    John Makely / msnbc.com

    A heavy police presence in lower Manhattan on Nov. 15.

    On the opposite side of Zuccotti park, the scene was quite different.

    John Makely writes:

    Broadway and Pine Street were flooded with protesters who had either fled Zuccotti Park when the police began clearing it or arrived afterwards and could get no closer.  Protesters were standing on NYPD vehicles and sitting in the middle of the intersection.

    While the scene wasn't tense there was an expectation that something would happen. Reinforcements beefed up the NYPD ranks and they warned those within earshot to clear out. Violent pushing, shoving and some punching later and the protesters were back on the sidewalk. Then a projectile was thrown from the crowd toward the police and about 30 seconds later there was a surge into the sidewalk by about 20 officers to attempt to catch whoever had thrown the object.

    Jonathan D. Woods / msnbc.com

    Police clear protesters from the area around Zuccotti Park on Nov. 15.

    Tense expressions on the NYPD and vocal rants from the protesters, some taunting, "The more you attack us the stronger we get", some trying to find common ground. One officer yelled back "Shut your mouth!"

    Police opened up a sidewalk leading to Zuccotti Park, which now stands freshly washed, with new barricades and a lot more officers.

    Follow @jmakely_917

    John Makely / msnbc.com

    NYPD officers surround Zuccotti park after cleaning crews finished removing tents and power-washing the plaza.

    Jonathan D. Woods / msnbc.com

    Members of the press, including John Makely of msnbc.com, center, work alongside tired protesters near Zuccotti Park early on Nov. 15.

    Read our latest news story on the clearance of Zuccotti Park and see more coverage of the Occupy Wall Street movement on PhotoBlog.

    12 comments

    The police had no right to clear out the protesters in the par The park is privately owned and the protestors were told they could return after the cleanup

    Show more
    Explore related topics: police, protest, new-york-city, us-news, breaking-news, featured, photographers-view, jwoods, john-makely, occupy-wall-street, zuccotti-park
  • 13
    Oct
    2011
    11:26am, EDT

    A 360 degree view of the Occupy Wall Street encampment at Zuccotti Park

    By John Makely, NBC News

    For nearly a month the Occupy Wall Street protesters have been camping in Zuccotti park, but that may change soon. Mayor Bloomberg has announced that cleaning crews will soon begin to clean the park and that protesters will be allowed to return as the work is completed. 

    The panorama image above was taken on Oct. 11 and consists of over 75 images stitched together with software to represent an immersive view of Zuccotti Park.

    Related story: Old guard back in the trenches at 'Occupy' protests

    Meet more participants in "Occupy" protests nationwide

    John Makely / msnbc.com

    Phil Lendz offers a free shave to a customer at the Occupy Wall Street encampment in Zuccotti Park.

     

    155 comments

    Get off the street and get a job!

    Show more
    Explore related topics: new-york, us-news, panoramic, ows, john-makely, occupy-wall-street
  • 6
    Oct
    2011
    11:08am, EDT

    Who is occupying Wall Street? Not just your average Joe

    msnbc.com visited the Occupy Wall Street protesters at Zucotti park in New York this week. Here are some of the people we met.

    John Makely / msnbc.com

    Shane Stoops prepares meals for others gathered at Zucotti Park on Oct. 5 for the Occupy Wall Street protest.

    by Miranda Leitsinger / msnbc.com

    Shane Stoops, a 23-year-old self-described “renaissance man” and nomad from Port Orchard, Wash., said he learned of the protest on his first night in the city – which happened to be the second day of the encampment. He has been there ever since, doing what he can to help keep the movement running. Today, he is helping prepare food for the demonstrators. Stoops is also handing out his resume daily.

    “I’ve just been here learning what there is to know. … I didn’t even know that a protest was going to be going on.”

    What keeps you here?

    “There are a lot of different messages going on here. However, we have one common one: We don’t want big business owning any of us anymore. We’re tired of that.”

    How long will you stay here?

    “I’m definitely committed until we are either arrested or beaten to death.”

    What would be mission accomplished?

    “Mission accomplished would be when the entire world is globally dynamic and we’re sitting here and nobody has to starve death. … I want the world to be united.” He had earlier elaborated that a global dynamic was “where everybody works for a common goal for humanity,” such as ending starvation and providing free education.

    What do you say to critics of this movement?

    “We’re too big to ignore now. We’re opening more and more eyes.”

    What do you think this movement could become?

    “A global revolution. I believe that every race, every religion, every person in the world can eventually come to terms with that -- we can all work together.”

    John Makely / msnbc.com

    Elad Ozeri, 31, brings his son Ron, 18 months old, to the Occupy Wall Street march.

    Elad Ozeri, 31, from Jerusalem, Israel, came down to the protest with his 18-month old son, Ron. He moved to New York two months ago, where his wife is studying for her doctorate. It was his first day at the camp, and he said he’ll try to spend a week there. While he spoke with msnbc.com, Ron ate a bagel and toddled around his dad.

    Why are you here?

    “We had a similar demonstration in Israel the whole summer. … I think it was almost the same idea but maybe it was more political in Israel, I don’t know. … It’s (the protest there) how to live, how to make a living, how to pay the rent and you know, I think the idea is to stop the robber barons. … And I think it’s the same idea here: to have a decent life, a simple life.”

    What’s your specific grievance?

    “I’m not against people with a lot of money but it depends where the money comes from.”

    Do you think this movement could grow?

    “I do think that it has the potential” but it must become populist, “so more people can relate to that.”

    What would make you think mission accomplished?

    “I just say enough for what’s happening. … I’m not a citizen here and I’m not that involved, but I think it’s just important to be here, for me.”

    John Makely / msnbc.com

    Sade Adona, 25, in New York with other Occupy Wall Street protesters on Oct. 5.

    Sade Adona, a 25-year-old from Oakland, Calif., now residing in Brooklyn, has lived at the camp site for 1.5 weeks and said she is in for the long haul. At one of her three jobs, her hours were cut severely; at another, they cut a program she was teaching. Financial troubles forced her out of her apartment and to take a semester off of school. She now rents a room in a friend’s place.

    Why are you here?

    “There are just a lot of things going on … I feel like it’s greatly important to be a part of the cause, everybody counts. … I’m down here to support; I’m down here to, like, just make sure that I am aware of what’s going on so that I can report back to others,” she said, noting she was first moved to join the protest by the recent execution of Troy Davis in Georgia and also was concerned about the tough economic times and employment opportunities.

    What do you say to critics?

    “I want to hear where they’re coming from,” Adona said.

    She also pushed back criticism from some saying “that we are just, like, angry college-age students” and “lazy” … (but) I’m here in between time camping out when I’m not at work.”

    What would be mission accomplished?

    “The acknowledgement is good enough for me,” such as a nod from the federal government of the movement, she said. “But if people were still out here and there was a reason, and I could find myself on accord with that reason, I would probably be out here still.”

    John Makely / msnbc.com

    Sue VanDerzee, 65, left, and Gloria Earls, 66, both from Connecticut, join the crowd for the Occupy Wall Street march.

    Grandmothers and friends, Gloria Earls, a retired teacher from Middletown, Conn., and Sue VanDerzee, a retired newspaper editor from Durham, Conn., traveled to the Occupy Wall Street site for the day and they hope to come back with more people.

    Why are you here?

    “I’m here to protest against corporate greed ... It seems like money is the bottom line for any action that our country takes,” said Earls, 66.

    “We’re worried about our grandkids, too. … I want our grandkids to grow up and, you know, have a world to live in, and Americans use way too much of it,” said VanDerzee, 65.

    What do you want?

    To “take money out of politics” and to “stop the wars,” VanDerzee said.

    What do you hope this becomes?

    “If it has to be a revolution, it may be just that time – and I’m willing to work for that,” Earls said.

    How do you respond to critics of this movement?

    “Get your head on straight and, you know, look around.  It’s not as rosy as they’re painting it,” Earls said.

    John Makely / msnbc.com

    Ashley Valdespino and Luis Lluicota in Zucotti Park for the Occupy Wall Street march.

    Friends and college students Luis Lliguicota, 20, and Ashley Valdespino, 19, are also part-time workers who have had to take out loans to pay for their education. They study at a college north of the city.

    Why are you here? “The student loans and the financial aid that’s available. Basically, it’s a circle of debt with us. Like it’s over and over, I already owe money. And I think that education should be free or [cost] less money. … Our students are our future and that’s what needs to be addressed here,” Valdespino said.

    Lliguicota said his concern about corporate greed brought him downtown. He works in a grocery store, where the hours have been cut.

    “How are we going to get out of debt if we can’t even get money?” he said. “We’re working every day, every week, check by check.”

    How do you respond to critics of this movement?

    “They can’t relate … there is going to be negativity to anything anybody does,” Valdespino said.

    What do you think this could become?

    “The reason I am here is to see what can come out of this … I think it is uniting the people [of] our generation so far,” Valdespino said.

    “We need to be educated about what’s going on in the world so I am here for that,” Lliguicota said.

    What would be a mission accomplished?

    “I don’t know yet … [I’m] waiting for it,” Valdespino said.

    “I want to end corporate greed, so hopefully equality – you know, the way they distribute the wealth,” Lliguicota said.

    John Makely / msnbc.com

    John Reiner, 49, in Zucotti Park waiting for the Occupy Wall Street march to start.

    Jon Reiner, a 49-year-old New Yorker laid off three times since 2001 from marketing executive jobs, has been without work for five years despite sending out what he figures to be 2,000 resumes. Now a stay-at-home dad of two boys, he has journeyed down to the camp for four days while his sons are at school.

    What do you want?

    “To enforce the corporate tax code … corporations do everything they can obviously to find loopholes in the tax code to avoid paying their fair share.”

    What do you hope this movement becomes?

    “My hope would be that, like all great social movements, that it gets so large in number and influence that it fundamentally changes the priorities of our elected officials so that they believe then that it’s their obligation to serve individuals and not corporations.”

    What do you say to critics of this movement?

    “I think that most grassroots movements that I am aware of start out messy and disorganized but they do come together because there is some galvanizing need … I think it’s unfair to dismiss what is a real national crisis because it looks as though it’s less than serious.”

    What would make you go home (or say “mission accomplished”)?

    “I think that it’s important to maintain this as a national issue either in this park or by other means of organizing in a collective effort until there is significant change in the priorities of government, with regard to the government’s role in creating a more equitable economic system.”

    For more on Jon Reiner's story click here.

    John Makely / msnbc.com

    Dennis and Elizabeth Carbone prepare to march in the Occupy Wall Street protest.

    Retired New York City couple Elizabeth and Dennis Carbone have made a few trips to the camp since the protest began on September 17. At one time, they were resident managers of a corporate bed-and-breakfast. They had to live in a shelter once, and now a dispute over their rent may land them there again. Their 51-year-old son died from an illness earlier this year, just a few days after his home went into foreclosure.

    Why are you here?

    “The American people would like a piece of the pie. They’ve had enough … (of) the rampant greed,” said Elizabeth Carbone, 64.

    What do you want?

    “Bring home all the troops” and “remove the tax-exempt status from … every house of worship,” Elizabeth Carbone said.

    What do you hope that this movement becomes?

    Elizabeth Carbone wants leaders who “represent the people. Not the 1 percent, but the people, the real people: the oil in the wheel, the ones who work and toil every day.”

    What do you say to critics of the movement?

    “I would tell them that they are simply unconscious. … there’s 2 percent of the wealth left for 98 percent of the population to scramble over, okay, and that’s what they’re doing, scrambling.” 

    How long will you be here?

    “As long as the young people and this movement need our support, we’ll be here. We can’t do what they’re doing, they’re young. We did that before. But we’re here, to give them support, to [let them] know that we’re behind them,” said Dennis Carbone, 69. 

    John Makely / msnbc.com

    Jim Weatherby, 50, from New Briton, Conn., waits in Zucotti Park in New York for the Occupy Wall Street march to start on Oct. 5.

     

    Jim Weatherby, a 50-year-old father of three adult children from New Britain, Conn., is a state employee who works with adolescent and juvenile delinquent males. His wife is a teacher, and he said they are a middle class family struggling to make ends meet. They can’t save money, he said, noting that their biggest problem is that they can’t get out from credit card debt. He took a day off work to travel to the Occupy Wall Street site.

    Why did you come here?

    “The excesses of Wall Street, the economic collapse that happened under George W. Bush that led to the TARP bailout, two grossly mismanaged and unnecessary wars have led to the economic situation in this country and I think it’s time that the rich paid their fair share.”

    What do you want?

    “The Bush tax rates … should have been rolled back or done away with the last time it came up.”

    What do you hope this protest becomes?

    “I hope it calls attention to the problem and that our lawmakers hear us and see that we are – like the signs say – we are the 99 percent. The country is being run backwards; we’re serving the 1 percent,” he said, adding that he hoped it would make an impact on the 2012 presidential and congressional elections, galvanizing the middle and working classes.

    What do you say to critics of this movement?

    “They’re not listening. They don’t get it. They don’t understand that all we want is a fair opportunity to work, all we want is a fair tax structure that doesn’t favor the wealthy.”

     

    Follow @mimileitsinger Follow @mimileitsinger

    2095 comments

    where are the tea party...i thought they were ordinary people who protect ordinary people..

    Show more
    Explore related topics: us-news, ows, john-makely, occupy-wall-street
  • 11
    Sep
    2011
    1:51pm, EDT

    View a panoramic image of the National Sept. 11 Memorial

    By John Makely, NBC News

     

    After years of construction work the site has been transformed to honor the victims of the 2001 attacks. This panorama image is comprised of over 60 images, taken on August 30,  that were stitched together with software. To navigate use the tools at the lower left of the image to pan and zoom.

    More Sept. 11 anniversary coverage in PhotoBlog

    • A father pauses to remember his son at the WTC site
    • James Taylor and Paul Simon perform during the 9/11 ceremony in NYC
    • 'Tribute in Light' shines above New York as America remembers 9/11
    • Hundreds of Ground Zero workers observe a moment of silence
    • An illuminated view of the National 9/11 Memorial

    Read more about 9/11

    • World pauses to remember 9/11
    • Obama to push for unity on 9/11
    • After 9/11: A decade of deaths, marriages, war and peace
    • Slideshow: Remembering 9/11

    77 comments

    The memorial is beautiful! I'm glad it was done. It was deserved for all of those who lost their lives. I hope to make it to New York one day to see it. And I agree with Ms. Peart. America can, and should be very proud of it.

    Show more
    Explore related topics: sept-11, world-trade-center, new-york-city, us-news, panoramic, john-makely
  • 9
    Sep
    2011
    4:11pm, EDT

    Hundreds of Ground Zero workers observe a moment of silence

    By John Makely, NBC News

    Hundreds of construction workers stopped what they were doing Friday morning at Ground Zero to bow their heads at 9:08 a.m. Several air horns sounded off in unison at that time and the normally frantic pace of construction became quiet.

    Related:

    Decade after September 11, New Yorkers ready to move on

    Inside the "bigger, better" Trade Center

    Full Coverage

    John Makely / msnbc.com

    Workmen at the World Trade Center site in New York unfurl a flag following the moment of silence observed by all the workmen on the site at 9:08 am on September 9. They will not be working on Sunday.


    John Makely / msnbc.com

    Construction workers observe a moment of silence at 9:08am on 9/9 at the WTC site.

    John Makely / msnbc.com

    Workmen at the top of the Freedom Tower observe the moment of silence.

    John Makely / msnbc.com

    As early morning preparations were under way at the 9/11 Memorial, hundreds of workers observed a moment of silence at 9:08 a.m. The workers will not be at the site on Sunday so they took a moment to recognize the tenth anniversary on Friday.

    People gathered at Ground Zero observe a moment of silence on Friday, to honor the victims of 9/11.

    41 comments

    I'm getting a little scared about all the self-delusion that seems to be accompanying this anniversary. I have listened to interviews with people who laud how we all came together and how we are a better, stronger, more united country for having gone through all this together.

    Show more
    Explore related topics: nyc, wtc, 9-11, ground-zero, sep-11, john-makely
  • 9
    Sep
    2011
    6:41am, EDT

    An illuminated view of the National 9/11 Memorial

    By John Makely, NBC News

    For almost ten years the bulk of the construction work at Ground Zero has been on the vast infrastructure below ground. Now, seeing the memorial site illuminated by the rising towers, I'm relieved to see that this hallowed space  is surrounded by a vibrant city.

    To navigate the panorama above use the tools in the lower left corner. The panorama consists of about 35 separate images stitched together with software to represent a 180 degree view of the site.

    John Makely / msnbc.com

    Workmen put the finishing touches on the south reflecting pool in preparation for the opening of the National 9/11 Memorial in New York City.

    From the archive: To see a 24-hour time-lapse of the construction at the World Trade Center site in September 2010, click the link below.

    A 24-hour time-lapse video of construction at the site as crews race to finish the Memorial and museum before the tenth anniversary. Photos by John Makely/msnbc.com

     

    71 comments

    i am proud to say my husband works on tower 1 as an ironworker...and to see this rising through his perspective is unbelievably humbling! thank you for this..its incredible!

    Show more
    Explore related topics: new-york, world-trade-center, us-news, 9-11, ground-zero, featured, panoramic, john-makely
  • 7
    Sep
    2011
    8:32am, EDT

    9/11 firefighter: Pride in his heart, dust in his lungs

    John Makely / The Baltimore Sun file

    Early in the morning on September 12, 2001 rescue workers remove debris by hand from the ruins of the World Trade Center towers as the sunlight hit the remnants of the north tower.

    By John Makely, NBC News

     The first time I took a picture of FDNY firefighter John Gates was September 12, 2001, at Ground Zero. Of all of the men and women there that day, digging through the wreckage, John stood out. His face said it all: Disbelief at what had just happened, the gravity of the events that were unfolding. The sadness we felt.

    I had arrived at Ground Zero around 3 AM on September 12.   At the time, I was living in Baltimore and working as a staff photographer for The Sun. When the first plane hit the North Tower, I checked in with my office and began making my way to lower Manhattan. When I arrived about 18 hours later, the scene was unfathomable.

    John Makely/ The Baltimore Sun file

    FDNY firefighter John Gates looks on as a stretcher carrying a rescued police officer is loaded into an ambulance while others applauded the rescue at Ground Zero on September 12, 2001.
    In a 2002 interview Gates talked about what he was thinking at that moment.
    "I was thinking about all my friends that could still buried in the rubble. It took a few days before you started to realize that you're probably not going to find anybody alive and that was kind of overwhelming that there were so many guys just from my firehouse alone, not to mention my cousin, Neil Leavy from 217 Engine who died in the collapse too. He was one of the first guys recovered, because he was in the south lobby, they found him within the first week. I didn't even know he was missing in this picture. I was still kind of hoping that they would find pockets of guys still alive."

    As I started working, I noticed two lines of firefighters forming amid the jagged debris. The firefighters passed down their lines a stretcher holding a Port Authority Police Officer who had been found alive deep in the wreckage of the towers. It had taken hours to free the officer, and as the stretcher got closer to the ambulance at the end of the line, applause began to build.  It would turn out to be one of the few bright spots in the months to follow.

     John Gates from Ladder 3 in the East Village was one of the firefighters in the line carrying the stretcher that day. To me, his expression captured the sadness, confusion, anger and so many other raw, inexplicable emotions that a lot of people were feeling. Even though his face had such an impact on me, he was at that time still just a face in the crowd. It wasn’t until a year later that I would even learn who John Gates was.

    John Makely/ The Baltimore Sun file

    New York Firefighter John Gates , photographed in front of the firehouse with other members of the company on July 28, 2002. He was originally photographed on Sept. 12, 2001 as he watched as a Port Authority policeman loaded into an ambulance after getting pulled alive from the rubble early in the morning on Sept. 12. As fellow rescue workers applauded, Gates looked on, hoping that they would find more people alive. His firehouse alone was missing twelve men.

     Ten years after that first image of John Gates standing in the line of firefighters at Ground Zero, his expression and everything it said still remains with me.  I visited with John again this year, documenting through still images and video how the 9/11 attacks affect him today, and what the past decade has been like for him.

    John Makely / msnbc.com

    Retired FDNY firefighter John Gates stands outside of the Ladder 10 firehouse, across the street from an entrance to the World Trade Centers construction site, on the day that President Obama came to the site to lay a wreath for the fallen. Gates was forced to retire after the toxic cloud of debris from the collapsing towers damaged his lungs.

    John Makely / msnbc.com

    Retired FDNY firefighter John Gates plays with his youngest son Oliver at home in Staten Island.

    John Gates was married just four months before the attacks. Today, he and his wife, Maricel, have two energetic boys. Still, there are reminders every day of what he lost on 9/11.  The toxic dust that John Gates inhaled during the attacks and in the weeks after that he spent searching through debris has left a permanent mark on him and over 1400 other FDNY personnel.  Besides the initial shock that all survivors had to overcome following the attacks, Gates now has to find a new path without the friends who died or the career he loved. Like many, moving forward after the attacks of 9/11 has been an ongoing challenge. This is my report:

    Retired New York firefighter John Gates' life was changed irrevocably by the toxic cloud at Ground Zero. Ten years later, he works to figure out a new path forward—while never forgetting the past.

     

    66 comments

    Just remember in December 2010, In the US senate , which political party filibustered taking care of the medical needs of these heros. Ill give you a clue, that party of new trash. The same party that screamed cruelty when tax subsidizes were proposed to be cut for oil companies in the same year. I  …

    Show more
    Explore related topics: new-york, sept-11, attacks, us-news, 9-11, ground-zero, featured, fdny, john-makely

Browse

  • world-news,
  • us-news,
  • featured,
  • sports,
  • weather,
  • protest,
  • politics,
  • asia,
  • india,
  • china,
  • europe,
  • space,
  • religion,
  • afghanistan,
  • middle-east,
  • environment,
  • travel,
  • london,
  • germany,
  • military,
  • animal-tracks,
  • tech-science,
  • jwoods,
  • japan,
  • fire,
  • south-asia,
  • conflict,
  • israel,
  • new-york,
  • russia,
  • pakistan,
  • cosmic-log,
  • snow,
  • egypt,
  • animals,
  • images,
  • entertainment,
  • business,
  • spain,
  • africa,
  • england,
  • earthquake,
  • flood,
  • libya,
  • syria,
  • economy,
  • winter
Also
Advertise | AdChoices

John Makely

is a Senior Multimedia Producer for NBCNews.com in New York.

  • Follow me on Twitter

Archives

  • 2013
    • May (83)
    • April (172)
    • March (186)
    • February (195)
    • January (251)
  • 2012
    • December (262)
    • November (281)
    • October (371)
    • September (319)
    • August (406)
    • July (387)
    • June (386)
    • May (422)
    • April (425)
    • March (458)
    • February (451)
    • January (502)
  • 2011
    • December (452)
    • November (464)
    • October (441)
    • September (409)
    • August (507)
    • July (439)
    • June (456)
    • May (443)
    • April (403)
    • March (421)
    • February (508)
    • January (651)
  • 2010
    • December (634)
    • November (360)
    • October (188)
    • September (159)
    • August (110)
    • July (89)
    • June (146)
    • May (89)
    • April (71)
    • March (46)
    • February (43)
    • January (54)
  • 2009
    • December (54)
    • November (46)
    • October (36)
    • September (40)
    • August (31)
    • July (39)
    • June (32)
    • May (57)
    • April (41)
    • March (38)
    • February (44)
    • January (45)
  • 2008
    • December (72)
    • November (38)
    • October (40)
    • September (40)
    • August (75)
    • July (36)
    • June (37)
    • May (44)
    • April (34)
    • March (52)
    • February (45)
    • January (26)
  • 2007
    • December (36)
    • November (32)
    • October (72)
    • September (60)
    • August (40)
    • July (23)
    • June (25)
    • May (31)
    • April (43)
    • March (38)
    • February (35)
    • January (47)
  • 2006
    • December (64)
    • November (77)
  • 2000
    • October (1)

Most Commented

  • Buggy hordes of cicadas sighted in Virginia ... but New York? Not yet (70)
  • Navy launches drone from aircraft carrier for first time (66)
  • Angry Maserati owner hires men to smash up his $420,000 supercar (38)
  • Man accidentally saws off arm, retrieves it, drives himself to hospital where it is reattached (29)
  • 'The World at Night' can be brightly beautiful – but there's a dark side, too (17)
  • Lava fountain, ash cloud erupt from Alaska volcano (14)
  • Microscopic crystal 'flowers' build themselves in a Harvard lab (11)

Other blogs

  • The Body Odd
  • Cosmic Log
  • Red Tape Chronicles
  • US News
  • Open Channel

NBCNews.com top stories

3147,10
© 2013 NBCNews.com
  • News photos on NBCNews.com
  • About us
  • Contact
  • Help
  • Site map
  • Careers
  • Closed captioning
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy policy
  • Advertise